A comfortable retirement works out cheaper in Costa Rica — around £2,100/month for a couple, versus £2,700 in Italy (about 22% more).
Cost of living, side by side
| Costa Rica | Italy | |
|---|---|---|
| Modest (couple/mo) | £1,500 | £1,900 |
| Comfortable (couple/mo) | £2,100 | £2,700 |
| Premium (couple/mo) | £3,400 | £4,300 |
Indicative monthly estimates for a couple — real costs vary by location, lifestyle and exchange rates.
Costa Rica: Foreigners can buy and hold titled property with the same freehold rights as Costa Rican citizens. The main exception is the Maritime Zone: the first 200 metres from the high-tide line, where the initial 50 metres are public and the next 150 metres are usually held under renewable concession rather than outright title.
Italy: Foreigners can buy property freely in Italy.
Costa Rica: The Pensionado residency suits retirees with at least US$1,000 a month of lifetime pension income, while the Rentista route uses stable unearned income or a bank deposit; both are renewable and can lead to permanent residency.
Italy: The elective residence visa suits retirees with stable passive income.
Costa Rica: Costa Rica is well regarded: legal residents join the public CAJA system by income-based contribution, alongside excellent private hospitals such as CIMA and Clinica Biblica in San Jose. Many keep private cover too, which is good value.
Italy: Italy's public health service (SSN) is well regarded and low-cost; retirees on an elective-residence visa register voluntarily for a means-tested annual fee starting around EUR 2,000 (capped near EUR 2,800 for higher incomes), or use comparatively affordable private cover. Facilities are generally strongest in the north and larger cities.
Costa Rica: Taxation is territorial, so a resident's foreign pension and overseas income are not taxed in Costa Rica, only locally sourced income is. That makes a UK or other foreign pension straightforward to draw here, though you keep any home-country obligations.
Italy: As a resident you are taxed on worldwide income including foreign pensions at progressive rates, but retirees moving to a small town (population under 30,000) in the eight southern regions can elect a flat 7% tax on all foreign income for up to ten years. UK government-service pensions are usually taxed only in the UK under the double-tax treaty, so take advice.
Costa Rica: Tropical with a dry season December to April and a greener rainy season May to November; the Central Valley stays spring-like around 22-27C year-round while the coasts are hotter and more humid. Safe by regional standards with everyday care against petty theft; Spanish is the language but English is widely used in expat and tourist areas, and driving is on the right.
Italy: Warm Mediterranean summers and mild winters in the south and along the coasts, with colder, wetter winters and hot summers inland and up north. Spring and autumn (April-June and September-October) are the most pleasant times. Italy is safe with a relaxed pace, though petty theft occurs in tourist cities; they drive on the right, and while English is common in cities and tourist areas, some Italian makes daily life far easier in smaller towns.
Costa Rica: Expect total one-off costs of about 5-6%: a 1.5% transfer tax plus registry stamps, with the balance for notary and legal work; foreigners are treated like locals outside restricted coastal concession zones. Purchases usually complete within a few weeks.
Italy: Registration tax is 9% for a second home or 2% for a main residence, charged on the property's cadastral value which is usually well below the market price (new-builds carry VAT of 10% instead), plus notary fees and agent commission of around 3% plus VAT. Completion typically takes two to three months.
Costa Rica: The Central Valley towns of Escazu, Santa Ana, Atenas and Grecia for a spring-like climate and expat services, plus Guanacaste (Tamarindo, Nosara) and the Central and South Pacific (Uvita, Dominical) for the beach.
Italy: Puglia and Abruzzo for affordable, sunny southern living and the 7% flat-tax towns; Tuscany and Umbria for classic rolling countryside; the northern lakes such as Como for scenery; and Liguria for a milder coastal base.
Thinking seriously about Costa Rica or Italy?
Two honest Brits, a private call, and straight answers — see if a freehold home abroad is a fit for you.
See if you qualify →